Heritage report ‘misunderstanding’

Rosemary Sorensen | Bendigo Weekly | 24-Nov-2011 12.22pm

«
"It will mean we are not just protecting something because it is pretty or attractive, but because it’s connected to the city"
»
A REPORT soon to be released by City of Greater Bendigo council will be used to justify future heritage decisions.

“I think there’s been a misunderstanding about what it is”, Director Planning and Development Prue Mansfield said this week.

“We are not writing a history.

“This is a precursor to lead into our heritage work, to underpin the significant themes of Bendigo’s environmental history.

“We will then use it to say what needs to be protected.”

Council was awarded a $20,000 Heritage Victoria grant towards a $60,000 project to create a Thematic Environmental History.

Melbourne-based consultancy Lovell Chen was engaged to write the report, currently in draft form.
Local historians are concerned the report has relied on published work without permission.

“I believe they should write their own report, and not take slabs of other people’s work,” James Lerk said.

“It leaves a very uncomfortable feeling when you see your work that are people are profiting from.

“They have created a problem for themselves.”

One of the report’s authors, Anita Brady, said it is normal for reports to quote from many sources.

“This is standard methodology,” Ms Brady said.

“I understand the sensitivities, but this is not a report published to sell.

“In the final version, it is also our practice to thank those whose works we have relied on.”

Australian copyright law states that using any part of a work without permission may infringe copyright if “that part is an important part”. According to the Australian Copyright Council, if the part is “an important, essential or distinctive part of the original material”, using it without permission may be an infringement of copyright.

“We are building a body of knowledge,” Ms Mansfield said.

“When things are facts and dates, it’s not plagiarised.

“Attributions are really important, and we have impressed on Lovell Chen the critical nature of acknowledging the sources.”

Ms Mansfield said the report will “build our case” for heritage protection in Bendigo.

“It will mean we are not just protecting something because it is pretty or attractive, but because it’s connected to the city.” 

TLPB - selling now

Comment





Captcha Image